Subject: Re: Verilog RTL Synthesis ballot passes!
From: Paul J. Menchini (mench@mench.com)
Date: Mon Jul 01 2002 - 12:22:11 PDT
Bhasker,
Cliff wrote:
>> Do we need to have another call to discuss replies to the votes?
>>
>> Seems like the committee needs to respond and then everyone gets one more
>> chance to change their vote (in either direction).
To which you responded:
> Now that the ballot has passed, the WG has one more task at hand -
> that of responding to all the comments (both positive and
> negative). To make this task easier, I am looking for volunteers (that
> will form the ballot responsse team) who would be willing to review
> some of the comments and write up the responses. All the responses
> will later be discussed and reviewed by the entire WG. If you would
> like to be part of the ballot response team, please send me email.
I will be happy to review the responses (to give you an idea of how
RevCom will feel about them), but I don't have time to help you formulate
the responses.
> So here are the remaining steps:
> 1. Collect all comments into a single document - my task (Paul
> Menchini send me his comments in a nice Excel format that I plan to
> use to collect the rest of the comments. Paul, I hope you dont mind).
Quite the contrary, I encourage its use. I formulated that spreadsheet
because it's more or less standard with RevCom (staff is developing a
standard template that will soon be distributed). Using that format
will allow RevCom to easily understand what your BRC has done.
IIRC, the only thing you may need to do is add a "BRC response" column.
> 2. Distribute comments to the ballot response team and respond -
> ballot response team
> 3. Discuss ballot responses by entire WG - by all
> 4. Send recirculation ballot.
Looks good!
Paul
This archive was generated by hypermail 2b28 : Mon Jul 01 2002 - 12:30:14 PDT