Subject: [Fwd: Some comments on IEEE P1364.1/D1.7]
From: David Bishop (dbishop@vhdl.org)
Date: Thu Oct 04 2001 - 19:20:06 PDT
Bounced because the wrong "from" address was used.
-------- Original Message --------
From: owner-vlog-synth@eda.org
Subject: BOUNCE vlog-synth@eda.org: Non-member submission from [Sashi Obilisetty <sashi.obilisetty@transeda.com>]
From: Sashi Obilisetty <sashi.obilisetty@transeda.com>
Subject: Some comments on IEEE P1364.1/D1.7
All,
I have reviewed chapters 1-5 of D1.7. My comments are attached below.
I will not be attending the conf. call tomorrow, let me know if you have
any questions.
Cheers,
=====================================
Sashi Obilisetty
Vice President & General Manager
New England Development Center
TransEDA Inc.
71 Spit Brook Road #405, Nashua NH 03060
Ph: 603 891 0609 Fx: 603 891 1748
email : sashi@transeda.com web: www.transeda.com
======================================
--=====================_8925230==_
Content-Type: text/plain; charset="us-ascii"
Content-Disposition: attachment; filename="vlogsynthreview.txt"
1. Footnote on Page 8 should appear on Page 7; ignore if this is
a printing problem
2. Section 3, Page 9. Change the reference to 'Language Reference Manual'
to 'Language Reference Manual (see Section 2)'
3. Section 3, Page 9. LRM should refer to The Verilog language reference
manual, IEEE Std 1364-2001. (Question: What is our position on referencing
the LRM, will we always reference the 2001 LRM?)
How about adding the following definitions to Section 3:
i) Sequential Logic (currently defined in Section 4)
ii) Combinational Logic (currently defined in Section 4)
iii) metalogical (used in Section 4 (item a), not defined anywhere)
iv) transient delays (used in Section 4)
v) timeout clause / active timeout clause (used in Section 4)
vi) Synchronous
vii) Asynchronous ("asynchronous control" and "asynchronous data" used
in Section 4.2)
In addition, I believe it is a good idea to also introduce definitions for
"combinational outputs" and "combinational delays".
4. 5.2.2.1 - typo, should read "storage device" not "storage sevice"
5. For completeness, suggest that a new section 5.2.2.2 be added that
illustrates modeling of edge-sensitive storage devices with
synchronous set/reset
This archive was generated by hypermail 2b28 : Thu Oct 04 2001 - 19:33:23 PDT