RE: [sv-ec] Request to review ballot issues, Meeting Minutes April 13, 2009, Action Items

I agree with Scott. Given the issues to be addressed and the other
workload that people have, it may be more realistic to request a May 28
date.
Note that if there are any VPI changes required (i did not foresee any
right now) the CC committee will need a minimum of 1 week to adjust.
 
Francoise
       '


________________________________

	From: owner-sv-ec@eda.org [mailto:owner-sv-ec@eda.org] On Behalf
Of Scott, David
	Sent: Tuesday, April 14, 2009 2:15 PM
	To: Mehdi Mohtashemi; sv-ec@eda.org
	Subject: RE: [sv-ec] Request to review ballot issues, Meeting
Minutes April 13, 2009, Action Items
	
	
	Mehdi, fellow SV-EC members,
	 
	I have to confess I wasn't sure what I was committing to, and
since I haven't been through this process before, I was not expecting
the amount of work assigned to me yesterday.
	 
	I won't be able to start addressing any of my action items until
the end of next week.  This doesn't make me optimistic about reaching a
May 14 date -- perhaps possible, I can't prove it either way since I
haven't been through this before -- but a deadline two weeks later would
make me feel a lot more comfortable.  Can we request May 28?
	 
	Thanks,
	 
	-- David
	 

________________________________

	From: owner-sv-ec@server.eda.org
[mailto:owner-sv-ec@server.eda.org] On Behalf Of Mehdi Mohtashemi
	Sent: Monday, April 13, 2009 10:21 PM
	To: sv-ec@eda.org
	Subject: [sv-ec] Request to review ballot issues, Meeting
Minutes April 13, 2009, Action Items
	Importance: High
	
	

	The ballot issues were reviewed in today's sv-ec ballot
resolution meeting.

	The following is the list of issues which were identified as
being non-trivial.

	[also specified in Minutes]

	Issues that may not be trivial: 

	    row number, id number

	 1.   130       21

	 2.   143      188

	 3.   146      47

	 4.   147      181

	 5.   149      49  - expect it to have a difference of opinion

	 6.   150      50

	 7.   151      51

	 8.   156      55  - requires some discussion

	 9.   167      183

	10.   172      189

	11.   173      190

	12.   175      105

	13.   177      107

	14.   181      111

	15.   184      114

	16.   186      116

	17.   190      121

	18.   192      120

	19.   197      192

	 

	1) Please review the above items along with other sv-ec related
issues, 

	and their description in the ballot resolution spreadsheet [
sent out in the previous 

	meeting's agenda] and send in your input as to the feasibility
of resolving these 

	issues by May 14 2009.  

	If this is not achievable by the above date, please indicate
your estimate of time that 

	is required to address and resolve the issues. 

	We would need this answer no later than Wednesday April 15,
11:30am PST, to 

	prepare for p1800WG meeting on Thursday this week.

	 

	2) Minutes of April 13 2009 meeting is uploaded on the sv-ec
site:

	
http://www.eda.org/sv-ec/Minutes/SV-EC_Meeting_April_13_2009_Minutes.txt


	 

	3) Here is the Action Item list from today's meeting related to
the ballot issues:

	[also appended in Meeting minutes]

	===========   Action item list provided for sv-ec
===================
	===========        from April 13 2009 meeting
===================
	  AI: Mehdi - conduct an email vote on the trivial
items.[requires proposals]
	  AI: Steven - row 128, id 20; put together a proposal,  mantis
2634
	  AI: Steven - row 130, id 21, will gather some input on this. 
	  AI: Dave - row 131, id 184; put together a proposal.
	  AI: Arturo - row 132, 133,  id 30 & 31; write it up, both 132
and 133
	  AI: Stu  - row 134, id 35; writeup a proposal 
	  AI: Jonathan - combine rows 135-139 [ids: 36-40] into one
mantis item.
	  AI: Dave - row 140, id 186; put together a proposal.
	  AI: Dave      - row 141, id 43;  put together a proposal for
this
	  AI: Jonathan - row 142, id 44; will put together a proposal.
	  AI: Dave - row 143, id 188; will look into 141, 144
	  AI: Dave - row 144, id 45; combine this  with row 141, id 43
	  AI: Stu - row 145, id 46; will write a proposal 
	  AI: Dave - row 147, id 181; follow-up on thisfor now 
	  AI: Gord - row 149, id 49  [not here, but on his list to
discuss/review]
	  AI: Francoise - row 150, id 50; will follow-up for now
	  AI: Francoise & Gord   - row 151, id 51; will follow-up for
now 
	  AI: Francoise - row 152, id 52; will follow-up
	  AI: Francoise - row 153, id 67; will look at it. 
	  AI: Francoise - row 154, id 53; will follow-up. 
	  AI: Francoise - row 156, id 55; will follow-up, non-trvial
	  AI: Cliff - row 157, id 57; put together a proposal
	  AI: Dave - row 158, id 182; follow-up, proposal, maybe
trivial.
	  AI: Mehdi - row 159, id 58; editoral, assign to editor.
	  AI: Gord -  row 160, id 59;  related to id 50.
	  AI: Mehdi - row 160, id 60; editoral, assign to editor
	  AI: Mehdi - row 162, id 61; editoral, assign to editor
	  AI: Gord, & Francoise  - rows 163-166, id [59-62]; to
follow-up. 
	  AI: Dave  - row 167, id 183; follow-up, non-trivial
	  AI: Mehdi - row 168, id 80; proposal exists, add to email vote
	  AI: Mehdi - row 169, id 81; send to sv-ac;  sv-ec has no
change to recommend.
	  AI: Mehdi - row 170, id 101; send to sv-ac 
	  AI: Ray - row 171, id 102; put together a proposal
	  AI: Dave - row 172, id 102; follow-up, nontrivial
	  AI: Dave  - row 173, id 190; follow-up, nontrivial
	  AI: Mehdi - row 174, id 104; assign to editor.
	  AI: David Scott - row 175, id 105, follow-up, non-trivial 
	  AI: David Scott - row 176, id 106, follow-up, maybe trivial 
	  AI: David Scott - row 177, id 107, follow-up, non-trivial 
	  AI: Mehdi - row 178, id 108; assign to editor.
	  AI: Francoise - row 179, id 109; try to get more information 
	  AI: David Scott - row 180, id 110;  make sure it is a
duplicate
	  AI: Francoise - row 181, id 111; get more clarification.
	  AI: Mehdi - row 182, id 112, assign to editor
	  AI: David Scott - row 183, id 113, follow-up, trivial. 
	  AI: Arturo - row 184, id 114, put a proposal together;
non-trivial
	  AI: Mehdi - row 185, id 115; no change needed
	  AI: David Scott , Gord - row 186, id 116; follow-up.
non-trivial 
	  AI: Mehdi - row 187, id 117; assign to editor
	  AI: Mehdi - ro2 188, id 118; assign to editor
	  AI: Mehdi - ro2 189, id 119; assign to editor
	  AI: David Scott- row 190, id 121; follow-up, non-trivial.
	  AI: Mehdi - row 191, id 122; assign to editor
	  AI: Arturo - row 192, id 120, follow-up, non-trivial.
	  AI: Mehdi - row 193, id 134; send it to the sv-bc
	  AI: Mehdi - row 194, id 135; send it to the sv-bc (duplicate
of id 134)
	  AI: Mehdi - row 195, id 137; assign to editor
	  AI: Dave - row 196, id 185; follow-up, trivial. 
	  AI: Dave - row 197, id 192; follow-up, non-trivial.

	 

	 

	 


	-- 
	This message has been scanned for viruses and 
	dangerous content by MailScanner <http://www.mailscanner.info/>
, and is 
	believed to be clean. 
	-- 
	This message has been scanned for viruses and 
	dangerous content by MailScanner <http://www.mailscanner.info/>
, and is 
	believed to be clean. 


-- 
This message has been scanned for viruses and
dangerous content by MailScanner, and is
believed to be clean.