[sv-ec] Minutes of May 9th, 2005 available on sv-ec site

From: Mehdi Mohtashemi <Mehdi.Mohtashemi_at_.....>
Date: Mon May 09 2005 - 23:22:05 PDT
I have placed the unapproved minutes of    Monday May  9 the, 2005, 
meeting  on  sv-ec site.   www.eda.org/sv-ec/Minutes.html   

http://www.eda.org/sv-ec/Minutes/SV-EC_BallotRes_Meeting_May_9_2005_Minu
tes.txt  

- Mehdi 

==================================================================== 
Action items: (May 9, 2005)

  1) AI (Mantis 725): Arturo update proposals into combined/merged one
for 725
  2) AI (Mantis 714): Ray to modify the proposal to make corrections for
a,b page 334,
        and the text under the example also needs to be deleted. Place
the 
       .pdf file there.
  3) AI (Mantis 703): Ray to update the proposal with the friendly
amendment and 
            place pdf file.
  4) AI (item 95- Mantis 512): Brad - place the proposal to the mantis
database. 
  5) AI (Mantis 236): Gordon  add a bugnote, to effect that this was
reviewed and 
              discussed
  6) AI (Mantis 730): Brad place the proposal in new mantis item.
  7) AI: ALL REVIEW ALL APPROVED/CLOSED MANTIS items for editorial
correction  

 ======================================================================


1A) The total number of issues in ballot review bucket:	60 
1B) The number of issues that are resolved either 
     by ballot feedback or LRM changes, or withdrawn : 	43
1C) The number of issues left/unresolved:
17	
==============================================================

2. Approved/Closed/ Mantis items.
   on May 9, 2005:
	  7  ( Mantis 344 ) [approved on 5/9/05]
	  --  Mantis 246    [Resolved on 5/9/05  No-Bug]
   	  --  Mantis 384    [Closed on 5/9/05  as Duplicate of 514]
 	  --  Mantis 248    [Closed on 5/9/05  already fixed]
	  --  Mantis 171    [approved on 5/9/05 ]
	  --  Mantis 725    [approved on 5/9/05   combined proposals]
	  --  Mantis 724    [approved on 5/9/05]
	  --  Mantis 720    [approved on 5/9/05]
	  --  Mantis 715    [approved on 5/9/05]
	  --  Mantis 714    [approved on 5/9/05]  (friendly amendment)
	  --  Mantis 703    [approved on 5/9/05]  (friendly amendment )
	 95  ( Mantis 512)  [approved on 5/9/05   friendly amendment for
12.25
	101  ( Mantis 523)  [approved on 5/9/05   friendly amendment
	  --  Mantis 729    [approved on 5/9/05]
	  --  Mantis 340    [Closed  on 5/9/05  as duplicate of 523
	  --  Mantis 532    [Approved on 5/9/05 -- purely editorial
combined with svbc
	  --  Mantis 730    [approved on 5/9/05  --  putc return byte]

   on May 4, 2005:
	233  ( Mantis 317 ) [approved on 5/4/05]
	266  ( Mantis 695 ) [approved on 5/4/05]
	  8  ( Mantis 370 ) [approved on 5/4/05]
	188  ( Mantis 595 ) [approved on 5/4/05]
	199  ( Mantis 607 ) [re-approved on 5/4/05, additions to the
original]
	    
    Other  Mantis items approved on this day with majority votes 
	707
	708
	709
	710
	711
	712
	713	one abstain: Francoise (do not have simulation expert in
meeting)
	722	6 yes votes, 	
		1 abstain: Cliff (1.proposal looks good, 2. semi-complex
change
				  3. it may diminish consensus)
		2 No votes: Francoise (I do not think we need the
re-inactive region)
			    Dave (Have not had time to share this with
all experts)

	Positive vote issues 30/31/32
		(Mantis 549, 551, 553) have been withdrawn by Francoise.


   on April 28, 2005:
	 10  ( Mantis 409 ) [re-approved on 4/28/05]
	 22  ( Mantis 514 ) [approved on 4/28/05]
	240  ( Mantis 681 ) [Withdrawn, closed/resolved approved on
4/28/05]

   on April 25, 2005;
	  2  ( Mantis 219 ) [has merit but not feasible at this time] 
	  5  ( Mantis 319 ) [approved on 4/25/05]
	199  ( Mantis 607 ) [approved on 4/25/05]  [Not a BUG -
resolved]
	 10  ( Mantis 409 ) [approved on 4/25/05]
	      Mantis 384  ) [approved on 4/25/05] (duplicate of 514)

   on April 21, 2005:
	 36  ( Mantis 270 ) [has merit but not feasible at this time]
 	162  (Mantis 552  ) [Closed as no-bug]
	      Mantis 411  ) [approved on 4/21/05] duplicate

   on April 18, 2005:
	283  ( Mantis 615 and 662 ) [approved on 4/18/05]
	  1  ( Mantis 93  )  [approved on 4/18/05]
	281  ( Mantis 683 )  [approved on 4/18/05]
 	238  ( Mantis 671 )  [approved on 4/18/05]

   on April 15, 2005:
       	235  ( Mantis- 666)  [approved on 4/15/05]
	236  ( Mantis- 642)  [approved on 4/15/05,  re-approved 4/15/05]
   
   on April 12, 2005:
	232  ( Mantis- 652 ) [approved on 4/12/05]
	(**236  ( Mantis- 642 ) [approved on 4/12/05] **)
	189  ( Mantis- 596 ) [approved on 4/12/05]

   on April 11, 2005:
	250  ( Mantis- 636 ) [approved on 4/5/05, re-approved 4/11/05]
	252  ( Mantis- 637 ) [approved on 4/5/05, re-approved 4/11/05]
	229  ( Mantis- 644 )
   		On issue 229 (644): sv-ec vote is still valid [4/15/05]
		sent back to the champions for decision on this.
		Champions may want to divide this up to two sections
		- initialization of struct 
		- randomization     

	230  ( Mantis- 646 )
	163  ( Mantis- 554 ) [one abstain -- Neil, (not read)]
    	255  ( Mantis- 641 ) [one abstain -- Neil, (not read)]

   on April 5, 2005:
	 11  ( Mantis- 410 )
	109  ( Mantis- 537 )
	161  ( Mantis- 550 )
	237  ( Mantis- 616 )
	239  ( Mantis- 617 )
	(**250  ( Mantis- 636 ) **)
	251  ( Mantis- 643 )
	(**252  ( Mantis- 637 ) **)

	253  ( Mantis- 649 ) [combined with 254 into one Mantis (649)
	254  ( Mantis- 649 )
				[2 abstains: Francoise & Steven, no
knowledge of coverage]

	270  ( Mantis- 638 ) 
	271  ( Mantis- 639 ) [one abstain: Steven, not read the
proposal]
	272  ( Mantis- 640 )
	283  ( Mantis- 615 ) [Votes: 4 yes(Brad,Neil,Dave, Surrendra),
&Mehdi 
				3 abstain:(Ray,Francoise, Steven), and 1
No (cliff)]	

   Issues marked not feasible
	204

   Issues sent to other committees for review:
	125	294	(sv-cc)	 (vpi question)
========================================================================
-------------------------------------------------------------------

A) The total number of issues in ballot review bucket:	60 
B) The number of issues that are resolved either 
     by ballot feedback or LRM changes, or withdrawn : 	43
C) The number of issues left/unresolved:
17	
 POSITIVE  Ballot issues left in the bucket
-------------------------------------------------------------------  
   Positive (high)   (10)
   -----------------------------------------------------
	 13   412
	 23   517
	 24   520
	 36   270   (enhancement -- randomize)
	 94	511	( type assignments)
	 96	516	(type compatibility description)
	 97	518	( queues, arrays, page 51)
	 98	519	( empty array 
	 99	521	( queues, pattern assignment)
	100	522	( queues concatenation)
   Positive (Medium/Low)   (7)
     ----------------------------------------------------
	122	251	(enhancement -- coverage)  	
	123	253	( coverage)
	171	564	(cross program references)
	187	594	( interface access through clocking block)
	190	597	(unnamed clocking blocks in bnf)
	200	608	(clocking block value resolution)
	201	609	(##cycle meaning in 16.14
====================================================================
Received on Mon May 9 23:22:14 2005

This archive was generated by hypermail 2.1.8 : Mon May 09 2005 - 23:22:27 PDT