[sv-ec] Minutes of Meeting Tuesday April 5th, 2005

 
 I have attached the minutes of f2f meeting Tuesday April 5th 2005. I 
have also appended below the list items approved, remaining for next
Monday discussion and action item list.
Please note that we will have another meeting/conf. call on Monday
April 11th 2005, 11:00-1:00 pm which is our regular biweekly conf.
call time slot. I will send out a notice for this tomorrow as well.

Also note that one issue has been sent to our committee for review by
sv-bc, issue 1 in the main database. Please refer to the master
spreadsheet in the database, sheet for BC for reference.

- Mehdi
  On April 5, 2005:
    Issues assigned for Monday meeting from Tuesday discussion:
	229, 230, 232, 233, 235, 236
	238 & 189 (together), 240, 281
	
    Issues approved:
	 11 109 161 237 239
 	250	251 252 253 254
	270	271 272 283

   Issues marked not feasible
	204

Issues to be sent to other committees for review:
	125 -->  sv-cc
	229 -->  sv-bc  (the first portion)

Issues sent to sv-ec from other committees
	1	from sv-bc



Action items:
  1) For issues 270: Brad to place it on SVDB.
  2) For issues 271: Brad to place it on SVDB.
  3) For issues 273: Brad to place it on SVDB
  4) for issue 250  Ray, to fix the sentence, add to svdb
  5) for issue 252: Ray to place it in svdb.
  6) for issue 255: Brad to place proposal in the database
  7) for issue 229: Mehdi to send it to sv-bc for review/discussion of
the 
		   first portion, initialization
  8) for issue 229: Dave/Ray to put further details to the proposal for 
		   review next Monday.
  9) for issue 11: Brad to place the proper html proposal in svdb
 10) for issue 230: Dave to do the rewrite/rewording of the proposal
 11) for issue 233: Surrendra to write more clarification to the
bit-stream
		    operators for class, pack/unpack (for Monday
discussion)
 12) for issue 236: Ray to finish the proposal for default args, for
Monday 
		    discussion, 'has to be visible, by caller..'
 13) for issue 237: Brad to place into the svdb
 14) for issue 239: Brad to place into the svdb
 15) for issue 251: Brad to place into the svdb
 16) for issue 125: Mehdi to send to sv-cc for review
 17) for issues 254 & 254: Mehdi to add the proposal into svdb
 18) for issue 161: Brad to place into the svdb
 19) for issue 109: Brad to place into the svdb (Mantis 537)
===================================================================
==== Issues reviewed on April 5, 2005, 
==== Need more discussion on Monday April 11, 2005

Approve		Low		189	596	Entity-1 
Disapprove	High		229		Entity-4	
Disapprove	High		230		Entity-4
Disapprove	High		232		Entity-4
Disapprove	High		233		Entity-4
Disapprove	High		235		Entity-4	
Disapprove	High		236		Entity-4	
Disapprove	High		238		Entity-4	
Disapprove	High		240		Entity-4	
Disapprove			266		Entity-6
Approve	High		281		Entity-7

==== Issues sent to sv-ec by other committees for review 
Approve			1		Entity-4 

==== Issues reviewed on April 5, 2005, 
==== Votes were taken for resolution.

Approve		High		11		Entity-1
Approve		High		109		Entity-1 
Approve		Low		161		Entity-1 
Disapprove				204		Entity-2
Disapprove		Low		237		Entity-4	
Disapprove		Low		239		Entity-4
Disapprove		High		250		Entity-4
Disapprove		Low		251		Entity-4	
Disapprove		High		252		Entity-4
Disapprove		Low		253		Entity-4	
Disapprove		Low		254		Entity-4

Approve		High		270		Entity-7	
Approve		High		271		Entity-7	
Approve		High		272		Entity-7
Approve		High		283		Entity-7 

==== Issues sent to other committees for review 
==== 
Approve		Low		125	294	Entity-1
Disapprove	High		229		Entity-4 
	(first segment, initialization) 

==========================================================
==== Issues not yet discussed in the first meeting===
			issue #      mantis #


Disapprove	High		255		Entity-4
---------------------------------------------------------------
Approve		High		2		Entity-1  	
Approve		High		5		Entity-1  	
Approve		High		7		Entity-1  	
Approve		High		8		Entity-1  	
Approve		High		10		Entity-1  	
  	
Approve		High		13		Entity-1  	
Approve		High		22		Entity-1  	
Approve		High		23		Entity-1  	
Approve		High		24		Entity-1  	
Approve		High		30		Entity-1  		
Approve		High		31	551	Entity-1  		
Approve		High		32	553	Entity-1  		
Approve		High		36	270	Entity-1  		
Approve		High		94	511	Entity-1  	
Approve		High		95	512	Entity-1  	
Approve		High		96	516	Entity-1  	
Approve		High		97	518	Entity-1  	
Approve		High		98	519	Entity-1  	
Approve		High		99	521	Entity-1  	
Approve		High		100	522	Entity-1  	
Approve		High		101	523	Entity-1  	
		
----------------------------------------------------------------
Approve		Low		122	251	Entity-1  	
Approve		Low		123	253	Entity-1  	
Approve		Low		162	552	Entity-1  	
Approve		Low		163	554	Entity-1  		
Approve		Low		171	564	Entity-1  		
Approve		Low		187	594	Entity-1  	
Approve		Low		188	595	Entity-1  	 	
Approve		Low		190	597	Entity-1  	
Approve		Low		199	607	Entity-1  	
Approve		Low		200	608	Entity-1  	
Approve		Low		201	609	Entity-1  	
===============================================================