The following bug has been ASSIGNED.
======================================================================
http://www.eda.org/svdb/bug_view_page.php?bug_id=0000009
======================================================================
Reported By: dwsmith
Assigned To: daver
======================================================================
Project: SystemVerilog Errata
Bug ID: 9
Category: SV-EC
Reproducibility: always
Severity: feature
Priority: normal
Status: assigned
Type: Errata
======================================================================
Date Submitted: 06-02-2004 14:33 BST
Last Modified: 12-04-2004 23:24 PST
======================================================================
Summary: Erratum Queue Methods
Description:
http://www.eda.org/sv-ec/hm/1848.html
======================================================================
----------------------------------------------------------------------
dwsmith - 06-03-2004 15:46 BST
----------------------------------------------------------------------
http://www.eda.org/sv-ec/hm/1848.html
edited on: 06-03-04 15:46
----------------------------------------------------------------------
bpierce - 09-27-2004 11:51 BST
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Adding additional information.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
bpierce - 10-03-2004 23:12 BST
----------------------------------------------------------------------
To add additional information.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
pieper - 10-27-2004 13:29 BST
----------------------------------------------------------------------
The P1800 has voted to accept this change 10/26/04
----------------------------------------------------------------------
bpierce - 12-04-2004 23:24 PST
----------------------------------------------------------------------
In Draft 2, in 4.14.2.6 (push_front) and 4.14.2.7 (push_back), the type
'element_t' is missing between 'input' and 'item'.
Additionally, the proposal itself missed a required change in 4.14.2.4
(pop_front) and 4.14.2.5 (pop_back) from a return type of 'queue_type' to
'element_t'.
Moreover, the prototypes in this section are inconsistent. Some queue
modifying methods have 'ref' ports defined and some, such as 'delete',
don't. And the 'insert' method has the 'ref' port in the middle. In my
opinion, none of these prototypes should have 'ref' ports. But, if they
do, then every queue self-modifying method should have one and in the same
position.
These problems go beyond editorial issues.
(Also, I note without objection that in 4.14.2, both occurrences of
'mytype' are not italicized.)
Bug History
Date Modified Username Field Change
======================================================================
06-02-04 14:33 dwsmith New Bug
06-02-04 14:35 dwsmith Assigned To => daver
06-02-04 14:35 dwsmith Status new => assigned
06-02-04 14:39 dwsmith Bugnote Added: 0000005
06-02-04 14:39 dwsmith File Added: qmethod.pdf
06-02-04 14:42 dwsmith Resolution open => fixed
06-02-04 14:42 dwsmith Status assigned => resolved
06-03-04 15:36 sv-ec Bug Monitored: sv-ec
06-03-04 15:46 dwsmith Resolution fixed => reopened
06-03-04 15:46 dwsmith Status resolved => feedback
06-03-04 15:46 dwsmith Description Updated
06-03-04 15:46 dwsmith Bugnote Edited: 0000005
06-03-04 15:47 dwsmith Resolution reopened => fixed
06-03-04 15:47 dwsmith Status feedback => resolved
09-27-04 11:51 bpierce Bugnote Added: 0000096
09-27-04 11:51 bpierce Resolution fixed => reopened
09-27-04 11:51 bpierce Status resolved => feedback
09-27-04 18:51 bpierce Additional Information Updated
09-27-04 18:51 bpierce Resolution reopened => fixed
09-27-04 18:51 bpierce Status feedback => resolved
09-27-04 18:51 bpierce Type => Errata
10-03-04 23:12 bpierce Bugnote Added: 0000106
10-03-04 23:12 bpierce Resolution fixed => reopened
10-03-04 23:12 bpierce Status resolved => feedback
10-03-04 23:13 bpierce Additional Information Updated
10-03-04 23:13 bpierce Resolution reopened => fixed
10-03-04 23:13 bpierce Status feedback => resolved
10-27-04 13:29 pieper Bugnote Added: 0000173
10-27-04 13:29 pieper Resolution fixed => reopened
10-27-04 13:29 pieper Status resolved => feedback
10-27-04 13:29 pieper Category SV-EC => SV-LRM
10-27-04 13:29 pieper Status feedback => assigned
11-23-04 08:20 stuart Additional Information Updated
11-23-04 08:20 stuart Status assigned => acknowledged
11-29-04 17:18 pieper Category SV-LRM => SV-EC
12-04-04 23:24 bpierce Bugnote Added: 0000433
12-04-04 23:24 bpierce Status acknowledged => assigned
======================================================================
Received on Sat Dec 4 23:24:54 2004
This archive was generated by hypermail 2.1.8 : Sat Dec 04 2004 - 23:25:24 PST