RE: [sv-bc] Ballot for proposed changes for 1800-2008 Draft 3

From: Brad Pierce <Brad.Pierce_at_.....>
Date: Wed Apr 25 2007 - 18:57:33 PDT
According to 6.1 --

  "A data object is a named entity that has a data value associated with
it, such as a parameter, a variable, or a net."

-- Brad 

-----Original Message-----
From: owner-sv-bc@eda.org [mailto:owner-sv-bc@eda.org] On Behalf Of Mark
Hartoog
Sent: Wednesday, April 25, 2007 6:11 PM
To: Maidment, Matthew R; sv-bc@eda.org
Subject: RE: [sv-bc] Ballot for proposed changes for 1800-2008 Draft 3

SB1-1-1   yes _x__ no ___ abstain ___
SB1-1-2   yes _x__ no ___ abstain ___
SB1-1-3   yes ___ no _x__ abstain ___
   I'm confused about what the proposed change is here.
SB1-1-4   yes _x__ no ___ abstain ___
SB1-1-5   yes _x__ no ___ abstain ___
SB1-2-1   yes ___ no _x__ abstain ___
   I think there may be reasons for somethimes using the year and
sometimes not.
SB1-3-1   yes _x__ no ___ abstain ___
SB1-3-2   yes _x__ no ___ abstain ___
SB1-3-3   yes ___ no _x__ abstain ___
   What is the proposed change. I think a config is a design element. I
don't
   want it deleted.
SB1-5-1   yes _x__ no ___ abstain ___
SB1-5-2   yes _x__ no ___ abstain ___
SB1-5-3   yes ___ no _x__ abstain ___
   This needs a more detailed proposal. I'm not sure I agree with it.
SB1-5-4   yes _x__ no ___ abstain ___
SB1-5-5   yes _x__ no ___ abstain ___
   I noticed that table 5-1 appears after table 5-2.
SB1-5-6   yes _x__ no ___ abstain ___
SB1-6-1   yes ___ no _x__ abstain ___
    Not clear proposal to vote on.
SB1-6-2   yes _x__ no ___ abstain ___
SB1-6-3   yes ___ no ___ abstain ___
   Not clear proposal to vote on.
SB1-7-1   yes ___ no _x__ abstain ___
   I prefer my own proposal on this, MH-1
SB1-7-2   yes ___ no _x__ abstain ___
   I think we need a more complete proposal for this.
SB1-10-1  yes ___ no _x__ abstain ___
   I don't see a proposed change here, but there is an 
   answer to Stu's question that he can use.
SB1-10-2  yes ___ no _x__ abstain ___
   No real proposal, some re-org advice that the editor can consider.
SB1-11-1  yes ___ no _x__ abstain ___
   no proposal.
SB1-11-2  yes ___ no _x__ abstain ___
   not a real proposal, but maybe the editor can include.
SB1-11-3  yes ___ no _x__ abstain ___
   not a real proposal, but an answer to editors question
SB1-11-4  yes _x__ no ___ abstain ___
SB1-12-1  yes ___ no _x__ abstain ___
   not a specific proposal, but a re-org suggestion for the editor
SB1-16-1  yes ___ no _x__ abstain ___
   not a specific proposal, but a re-org suggestion for the editor
SB1-19-1  yes ___ no _x__ abstain ___
   not a specific proposal, but a re-org suggestion for the editor
SB1-19-2  yes _x__ no ___ abstain ___
SB1-20-1  yes ___ no _x__ abstain ___
  not a specific proposal, but a re-org suggestion for the editor
SB1-20-2  yes _x__ no ___ abstain ___
SB1-21-1  yes ___ no _x__ abstain ___
  not a specific proposal, but a re-org suggestion for the editor
SB1-21-2  yes _x__ no ___ abstain ___
SB1-21-3  yes _x__ no ___ abstain ___
SB1-22-1  yes _x__ no ___ abstain ___
SB1-22-2  yes _x__ no ___ abstain ___
SB1-22-3  yes _x__ no ___ abstain ___
SB1-22-4  yes _x__ no ___ abstain ___
SB1-25-1  yes _x__ no ___ abstain ___
SB1-25-2  yes _x__ no ___ abstain ___
SB1-25-3  yes _x__ no ___ abstain ___
SB1-27-1  yes ___ no _x__ abstain ___
  not a specific proposal, but a re-org suggestion for the editor
SB1-33-1  yes ___ no _x__ abstain ___
  I'm confused about what is the exact proposal
SB-O-1    yes ___ no _x__ abstain ___
  I think a configuration is a design element.
SB-O-2    yes ___ no _x__ abstain ___
  no proposal
SB-O-3    yes ___ no ___ abstain _x__
   I can't find this item.
SB-O-4    yes ___ no _x__ abstain ___
  no clear proposal
SB-O-5    yes ___ no _x__ abstain ___
  no clear proposal
SB-O-6    yes ___ no _x__ abstain ___
  no clear proposal
SB-O-7    yes ___ no _x__ abstain ___
  no clear proposal
SB-O-8    yes ___ no _x__ abstain ___
  no clear proposal
SB-O-9    yes ___ no ___ abstain _x__
   I can't find this item
SB-O-10   yes ___ no ___ abstain ___
  editing advice, but no clear proposal
SB-O-11   yes ___ no ___ abstain ___
  no clear proposal
SB2-6-9-1 yes _x__ no ___ abstain ___
BP1-5-1   yes _x__ no ___ abstain ___
BP1-5-2   yes _x__ no ___ abstain ___
BP1-5-3   yes ___ no _x__ abstain ___
  I'm not sure what 'data object' means.  Can't I assign a string
literal to a net?
BP1-5-4   yes _x__ no ___ abstain ___
BP1-5-5   yes ___ no _x__ abstain ___
  What is a data object?
BP1-5-6   yes _x__ no ___ abstain ___
BP1-5-7   yes ___ no _x__ abstain ___
  What is a data object?
BP1-5-8   yes ___ no _x__ abstain ___
  What is a data object?
BP1-6-1   yes _x__ no ___ abstain ___
BP1-6-2   yes _x__ no ___ abstain ___
BP1-6-3   yes _x__ no ___ abstain ___
BP1-6-4   yes _x__ no ___ abstain ___
BP1-6-5   yes _x__ no ___ abstain ___
BP1-6-6   yes _x__ no ___ abstain ___
BP1-7-1   yes _x__ no ___ abstain ___
BP1-7-2   yes _x__ no ___ abstain ___
BP1-7-3   yes _x__ no ___ abstain ___
BP1-7-4   yes ___ no _x__ abstain ___
  I like MH-1 better.
BP1-8-1   yes _x__ no ___ abstain ___
BP1-9-1   yes _x__ no ___ abstain ___
BP1-9-2   yes _x__ no ___ abstain ___
BP1-9-3   yes _x__ no ___ abstain ___
BP1-9-4   yes _x__ no ___ abstain ___
BP1-10-1  yes _x__ no ___ abstain ___
BP1-10-2  yes _x__ no ___ abstain ___
BP1-10-3  yes _x__ no ___ abstain ___
BP1-11-1  yes _x__ no ___ abstain ___
BP1-12-1  yes _x__ no ___ abstain ___
BP1-12-2  yes _x__ no ___ abstain ___
BP1-12-3  yes _x__ no ___ abstain ___
BP1-12-4  yes _x__ no ___ abstain ___
BP1-12-5  yes _x__ no ___ abstain ___
BP1-13-1  yes _x__ no ___ abstain ___
BP1-13-2  yes _x__ no ___ abstain ___
BP1-13-3  yes ___ no _x__ abstain ___
  I'm not sure about this.
BP1-13-4  yes _x__ no ___ abstain ___
BP1-13-5  yes _x__ no ___ abstain ___
BP1-13-6  yes _x__ no ___ abstain ___
BP1-13-7  yes _x__ no ___ abstain ___
BP1-22-1  yes _x__ no ___ abstain ___
BP1-22-2  yes _x__ no ___ abstain ___
BP1-22-3  yes _x__ no ___ abstain ___
BP1-22-4  yes _x__ no ___ abstain ___
BP1-22-5  yes _x__ no ___ abstain ___
BP1-A-1   yes _x__ no ___ abstain ___
MH-1      yes _x__ no ___ abstain ___
MH-2      yes _x__ no ___ abstain ___
MH-3      yes _x__ no ___ abstain ___
HC-D-1    yes ___ no _x__ abstain ___
  not a complete proposal, editing advice
HC-D-2    yes _x__ no ___ abstain ___
HC-E-1    yes ___ no _x__ abstain ___
  not a complete proposal, editing advice
HC-O-1    yes _x__ no ___ abstain ___
HC-O-2    yes _x__ no ___ abstain ___
HC-O-3    yes _x__ no ___ abstain ___
HC-O-4    yes _x__ no ___ abstain ___
HC-O-5    yes _x__ no ___ abstain ___
HC-O-6    yes _x__ no ___ abstain ___
HC-O-7    yes _x__ no ___ abstain ___

--
Matt Maidment
mmaidmen@ichips.intel.com
 

--
This message has been scanned for viruses and dangerous content by
MailScanner, and is believed to be clean.


--
This message has been scanned for viruses and dangerous content by
MailScanner, and is believed to be clean.



-- 
This message has been scanned for viruses and
dangerous content by MailScanner, and is
believed to be clean.
Received on Wed Apr 25 18:58:23 2007

This archive was generated by hypermail 2.1.8 : Wed Apr 25 2007 - 18:59:01 PDT